A shallow trench filled with wet, dark drain rock running across a sloped lawn, with ferns and moss at the top of the bank.

HomeGuidesFrench drain, curtain drain or dry well

Guide ยท Choosing a drain

French drain vs curtain drain vs dry well: which one fits your yard

All three deal with water you don't want, in different ways. A French drain collects water where it already sits, a curtain drain catches it on its way downhill, and a dry well gives water a place to soak in underground. Some yards need two of them working together.

A person answers and connects you with an independent, CCB-licensed drainage contractor serving Milwaukie, Happy Valley, West Linn, Tualatin, Lake Oswego, Oregon City and Wilsonville.

Illustrative photo

Start with where the water comes from

  • Water sitting in the soil of a low area or along the foundation: a French drain.
  • Water seeping down from uphill, showing up as a wet band below a slope or on the uphill side of the house: a curtain drain.
  • Water that has been collected by a downspout line or a drain, with no lower spot on the lot to send it to: a dry well, if the soil will take it.
A sloped, wooded backyard with a narrow gravel-filled trench running across the grass above a two-story house, a mossy boulder in front.
Illustrative photo: a gravel-filled trench across a sloped backyard above a house.

French drain

Cross-section of a French drain A trench in wet soil, lined with filter fabric and filled with washed drain rock around a perforated pipe. Arrows show water seeping out of the soil on both sides into the rock and pipe. A layer of soil caps the trench. Soil cap Filter fabric Washed drain rock Perforated pipe Wet soil
Diagram, simplified and not to scale: a French drain in cross-section.

A trench lined with filter fabric, filled with washed drain rock, with a perforated pipe near the bottom. Water in the surrounding soil moves into the rock, drops into the pipe and runs downhill to an outlet. It only moves water, so it needs somewhere lower to send it: a low spot on the lot, a dry well, or a storm connection where the city allows one.

Published ranges: $27 to $42 per linear foot in Portland, according to HomeBlue's 2024 page,1 and $2,800 to $6,500 for a typical project nationally, according to Fixr.2 More in the French drain cost guide and on the French drain page.

Curtain drain

Side view of a curtain drain on a slope Ground slopes down from left to right toward a house. Water moves downhill through the soil below the surface. A gravel trench with a pipe, dug across the slope uphill of the house, catches the water before it reaches the house. Water moving through the soil Curtain drain across the slope Uphill House downhill
Diagram, simplified and not to scale: a curtain drain intercepting water that moves down a slope through the soil.

Built almost the same way as a French drain, but placed across the slope uphill of what you want to keep dry. It intercepts water moving downhill through the soil and carries it around the house to an outlet. Fixr puts curtain drains at $10 to $25 per linear foot, for a total around $1,000 to $2,500.2

On a slope, where that water ends up matters. DOGAMI, Oregon's geology agency, says that in an urban setting improper drainage is most often the factor when a landslide occurs.3 A curtain drain that dumps onto the slope below just moves the problem. This matters most on hillside lots, such as many in West Linn, Happy Valley and Oregon City. More on the curtain drain page.

Dry well

Buried downspout line A downspout on the side of a house turns into a solid pipe buried under the lawn. The pipe slopes away from the house and ends at a pop-up emitter in a lower part of the yard, with a dry well shown as another possible end point. Downspout Solid pipe, sloped away Pop-up emitter or dry well
Diagram, simplified and not to scale: a downspout tied into buried solid pipe that runs to a pop-up emitter or a dry well.

An underground chamber, or a pit filled with rock, that holds water and lets it soak into the ground slowly. It does not collect water from the soil the way a French drain does. It takes water that a pipe brings to it, usually from downspouts (see downspout drainage). Fixr puts a dry well at $1,500 to $5,000, depending on the material.2

A dry well only works if the soil around it drains. Wilsonville's stormwater plan says soils in the city are generally limited in how well they take in water (groups C and D),4 and in slow soil a dry well can fill faster than it empties. Portland's homeowner drywell guide calls for professional help where soil drains slower than 2 inches per hour, and says the bottom of a drywell must sit at least 5 feet above seasonal groundwater and at least 5 feet above hardpan or another layer water cannot pass through. The top has to be lower than nearby foundations.5 A simple hole test, described in the soggy yard guide, gives a first idea of how fast your soil drains.

Rules that apply to dry wells

  • State: Oregon DEQ treats a drywell as an underground injection control system, or UIC. It says a UIC that drains only roof runoff from a single-family home does not need DEQ authorization, while one serving a duplex or larger does. DEQ's UIC rules do not apply to French drains, swales or footing drains.6
  • Milwaukie: a homeowner who adds a drywell on its own, with no other work, applies for a site development permit.7
  • Oregon City: for permitted development inside the city's mapped geologic hazards overlay, Chapter 17.44 does not allow infiltration in areas steeper than 25 percent, and requires a geotechnical report to look at any infiltration facility that could affect nearby slopes steeper than 10 percent. Digging less than 2 feet deep or under 25 cubic yards is exempt from the chapter.8

When they work together

A French drain or curtain drain can end in a dry well when the lot has no lower spot and the soil drains well enough. Roof water usually gets its own solid pipe, because a storm's worth of runoff from the roof can overwhelm a drain that is built to take water in slowly from the soil.

Questions to ask before choosing

  • Where does the water come from, and when does it show up: during the rain, or days later?
  • Is there a spot on the lot lower than the wet area, where water can come out at the surface?
  • How fast does the soil drain where a dry well would go?
  • Is the lot steep, or inside a mapped hazard area, so the plan needs a geotechnical engineer or a city permit?

When you call, a person takes down where the water is and when it shows up, and an independent, CCB-licensed drainage contractor looks at the yard before recommending any of the three.

Guides

More drainage guides

Or see all guides.

A rain-soaked backyard at dusk, warm window light reflected on a wet stone patio, dark firs against a blue sky.

Tell a person what the water is doing.

One number for Milwaukie, Happy Valley, West Linn, Tualatin, Lake Oswego, Oregon City and Wilsonville. Say where the water collects and when it shows up.